Just sharing about version with best results so far
First of all, thank you for working on this great model ❤️
I tried from v17 to v23 - I would like to give some feedback maybe to improve v24 or above 👍
So far I get MUCH better results on v19 compare to anything.
v22 is pretty bad with lots of issues with extra limbs, v23 quality is better but still have lots of issues when I use 2 or 3 images for example 2 images and a background, it confuses between the characters pretty much ignore the prompt in many parts, unlike v19 is much more accurate and also gives better results.
v19 is not perfect in quality, but it is VERY accurate to prompt, still all of them sometimes gives extra limbs for some poses but I can't say which.
v19 is the winner so far,
I hope v24 will be different than v22 and v23 but as good as v19 with even better results 🤞
Keep up the good work!
I have to agree, I specifically tested. v19 is both better on protecting identities, it has more natural lighting, also I saw no degredation on prompt understanding after downgrading from v23. I love phr00ts work and mean no harm or offense but there is something wrong with newer versions for sure.
Will test today and return with my thoughts on v19 vs v23. Was getting lots of oom on every second generation with v23 anyways using a 5070 ti.
OP you're 100% correct, thank you as I was considering giving up on this AIO. v19 > v23.
With v23 I did:
photo 1 and photo 2: same subject, wanted both photos as they were different angles.
photo 3: Small details I wanted added to the subject from photo 1 and 2.
The results were hit and miss, sometimes great, sometimes terrible.
Tried the same exact prompt and photos today with v19 and the results were incredibly accurate. Had to do a lot of prompt engineering to even get v23 to do what v19 does and v19 still did it better.
Agree. I have not moved off of v19 since it came out. 1 in 50 runs gets "plasticy" but that's just a quick run through Z-Image.
v19 is not perfect, but my point is that it's the BEST out of anything above that I tried so far.
It's not that simple to compare because even v19 can have suddenly weird results, the thing is that it's having LESS issues and more hits! 👍
Maybe v20-v23 needs to be "deleted" so the START POINT for the next version will be v20 (new) instead of jumping to v24... which probably will be based on v23 and it's issues?
Just my 2 cents... 🤔
Agreed. I use v21 if doing anime->photo transformations, otherwise v19 all the way.